Tom Hu 在中国的塑胶企业背负 730,000 美元(约 0.73 百万美元)银行贷款,营收仅足以支应费用而难以负担债务成本;银行选择展延还款以避免帐上新增逾期贷款。官方不良贷款(NPL)比率长期约 1.5%,但多数经济学家认为显著低估;Absolute Strategy Research 的 Adam Wolfe 估计接近 10%,意味约 3 兆美元贷款本应列为逾期却未被认列,且亦有人认为可能达其 2 倍。
坏帐上升与「展期/宽容(forbearance)」政策密切相关:规则要求逾期超过 90 天且无法全额偿付即应列为不良,但经济学家估计约 40% 贷款符合或已进入某种宽容安排。Absolute Strategy Research 指出约 10% 上市非金融企业连续 3 年以息税前盈余(EBIT)无法覆盖利息;Dallas Fed 研究显示「僵尸企业」在 2024 年占中国非金融企业资产 16%,高于 2018 年的 5%。匿名官员与 Victor Shih 的估计甚至将真实 NPL 比率置于 15%–20%。
宏观层面上,中国于 2026 年将成长目标下调至 4.5%–5%,且政府拟对大型银行补充逾 1,000 亿美元资本;同时以特别国债在 2026 年发行 3,000 亿元人民币(约 3,000 亿 CNY),加上 2025 年的 5,000 亿 CNY。宽容政策涵盖 9.4 兆 CNY(约 9.4 兆元人民币)贷款并延长至明年年底,另有最长 2 年房贷宽限。银行亦加速核销与处置不良:自 2020 年起每年处置逾 3 兆 CNY,2024 年约 3.8 兆 CNY 创高;高风险金融资产占比则由 2017 年峰值 30% 降至 2025 年底 4.9%,Morgan Stanley 的 Richard Xu 预期 2027 年约 3%。
Tom Hu, a plastics business owner in China, carries a USD 730,000 bank loan yet earns barely enough to cover expenses and cannot meet debt-service costs; instead of calling the loan, the bank allows deferrals to avoid adding another past-due exposure. China’s official non-performing loan (NPL) ratio sits near 1.5%, but many economists argue it is far higher: Adam Wolfe of Absolute Strategy Research estimates about 10%, implying roughly USD 3 trillion of loans that should be classified as past due are not, with some suggesting as much as double.
The gap is driven by widespread forbearance. Although rules say a loan overdue by more than 90 days that cannot be fully repaid should be marked nonperforming, economists estimate about 40% of loans are eligible for or already in some form of forbearance. Absolute Strategy Research finds about 10% of listed non-financial firms have failed to cover interest from EBIT for three consecutive years, while a Dallas Fed study estimates “zombie firms” rose to 16% of non-financial corporate assets in 2024 from 5% in 2018. Anonymous officials and Victor Shih place the true NPL ratio at 15%–20%.
Policy responses aim to preserve stability but risk prolonging weak growth. China lowered its 2026 growth target to 4.5%–5% and is recapitalizing major banks with over USD 100 billion; it will issue CNY 300 billion in special sovereign bonds in 2026 on top of a CNY 500 billion program in 2025. Small-business loan rollovers cover CNY 9.4 trillion through late next year, and some underwater mortgages receive up to two-year payment holidays. Banks are also accelerating write-offs and transfers, disposing of more than CNY 3 trillion of NPLs annually since 2020 and about CNY 3.8 trillion in 2024; meanwhile, high-risk financial assets fell to 4.9% of total assets by end-2025 from a 30% peak in 2017 and are projected near 3% by 2027, per Morgan Stanley’s Richard Xu.